The Problem of Emotionally Unhealthy Spirituality
Following Jesus without emotional health can be deadly. It can hurt you, your relationship with God, and the people around you. The author, Pete Scazzero, learned this the hard way. He was the pastor of New Life Fellowship Church in Queens, New York. And he tells a story he wishes he could forget.
One hot Sunday in July, a visiting couple named John and Susan drove a long way to attend the church’s three services. Between services, they asked to spend some time with Pete and his wife, Geri. Pete was exhausted. But the couple’s pastor was a friend of his, and Pete worried what they would say about him if he sent them home. So he lied. “Sure, I would love to have you for a late-afternoon lunch. I’m sure Geri would too!”
At the kitchen table, John talked, and talked, and talked. Susan said nothing. Pete pretended to listen. Inside, he was angry, and then he felt guilty for being angry. After a long time, during a rare pause, Geri spoke up. “I haven’t heard from Faith in a while.” Faith was their three-year-old daughter. John kept right on talking.
Finally, Geri went to look. No Faith in the basement. No Faith in the bedrooms. She ran back into the kitchen. “Pete! Oh my God, I can’t find her. She’s not here!” They ran to the small pool in the backyard. There stood Faith, in the middle of it, on her tiptoes, with the water up to her chin. If she had slipped, they would have been burying their daughter.
Looking back, Pete saw the truth. “John wasn’t the problem; I was.” On the outside, he had looked kind and patient. On the inside, he was nothing like that. He wanted so badly to look like a good Christian that he shut out what was really going on inside him. Pretending was safer than honesty and vulnerability. And because of that, Faith almost died. Even then, nothing changed inside him. That would take five more years and a lot more pain.
How could a pastor live like this? Pete had become a Christian at nineteen, gone to seminary, and started a church. But for seventeen years, almost no one talked about the emotional side of life. So that part of him stayed untouched.
Church life can even become a hiding place. When people meet God in worship, prayer, and Bible study, they assume they are doing fine. They think this even when their relationships are broken and their inner life is a mess. Pete compares a person to an iceberg. Only about 10 percent of an iceberg shows above the water. That is the part people see: we go to church, act nicer, and clean up bad habits. But most of who we are sits below the surface. And a large part of it stays untouched by Jesus.
Three things finally forced Pete to look below the surface. First, he had no joy, even though Jesus promised, “My yoke is easy and my burden is light.” Second, he was angry and depressed. His church had an afternoon service in Spanish. When Pete’s associate in that Spanish service left to start a church of his own, he took two hundred of its two hundred and fifty members with him. Pete found himself hating the man. He preached love and forgiveness on Sundays and cursed alone in his car on Mondays.
The third thing was Geri. She was lonely and tired of raising their four daughters like a single mom. One evening, she walked into their bedroom and calmly told him, “Pete, I’d be happier single than married to you.” Then she added, “Oh, yes, by the way, the church you pastor? I quit. Your leadership isn’t worth following.” Pete now calls it probably the most loving thing Geri has done in their whole marriage. She had seen something vital. It is not possible to be spiritually mature while remaining emotionally immature.
Without emotional growth, people get stuck. As one man in Pete’s church put it, “I was a Christian for twenty-two years. But instead of being a twenty-two-year-old Christian, I was a one-year-old Christian twenty-two times!”
Pete names ten warning signs of this stuck kind of faith. The first is using God to run from God, staying busy with church activity to avoid what God wants to change. The second is ignoring anger, sadness, and fear. The third is dying to the wrong things. You are called to die to your sin, not to God’s good gifts, like friendship, music, laughter, and nature. The fourth is denying that your past shapes your present. The fifth is splitting life into sacred and secular. Think of the man who sings about God’s love at church and then wishes another driver dead on the way home.
The sixth sign is doing for God instead of being with God. The seventh is sweeping conflict under the rug. The eighth is hiding weakness and failure. The ninth is living without limits. And the tenth is judging other people’s spiritual journeys.
So what is the way out? Pete joins emotional health with what he calls contemplative spirituality, which simply means a slower, quieter life of being with God. The rest of the book walks through seven pathways. Know yourself. Look back at the family you came from. Go through a hard season Pete calls the Wall. Grieve your losses. Slow down with daily prayer and a weekly Sabbath. Grow up emotionally, so you can love people well. And make a simple plan to keep it all going. The first pathway is knowing yourself so that you may know God.