The Comfort Crisis

Humans evolved with hunger, cold, boredom, and hard work. Now comfort is everywhere, and people are living longer but sicker. Alongside a 33-day caribou hunt in the Arctic, Easter digs into the science of discomfort and shows how small, chosen doses of it, from boredom and silence to hunger and heavy carries, can leave you healthier, calmer, and more alive.

Part One

Why We Need Discomfort

33 Days

Michael Easter stood on a windy tarmac in Kotzebue, Alaska, 20 miles above the Arctic Circle, staring at two tiny bush planes. Picture empty Campbell’s soup cans with wings. He was no fan of flying. Donnie Vincent, the backcountry bowhunter and filmmaker who had planned the trip, assured him he’d booked the best pilot around, a man named Brian. Brian did have a colleague named Mike, Donnie added, who had recently crashed after misreading the weather.

The planes would drop them deep in the Arctic, among grizzlies, wolves, and whiteout storms, hundreds of miles from the nearest hospital. For 33 days, they would hunt caribou on foot. None of it sounded like Easter’s safe, comfortable life at home. And that was the point. Most people now live sheltered, temperature-controlled, overfed, underchallenged lives, and they miss much of what the poet Mary Oliver called their “one wild and precious life.” A radical new body of evidence shows that people are at their best after facing the same discomforts their ancestors faced every day. This trip sat at the extreme end of that prescription. You can get the same benefits in smaller doses at home, like boredom, silence, hunger, and carrying heavy things, and between scenes from the Arctic, the book shows how.

But before any of that, Easter had to survive the flight. Donnie and Brian took off first, which left him squeezed into the backseat of a small Cessna. A young pilot in aviator sunglasses climbed in, reached back a gloved hand, and introduced himself. His name was Mike.

35, 55, or 75

Years before that flight, Easter faced a different kind of danger. His father once got drunk on St. Patrick’s Day, painted his horse green, and rode it into a bar. By his twenties, Easter was riding the same family horse. He was a health journalist telling readers how to live better, while most of his own energy went to drinking. Alcohol was his comfort blanket. It killed stress, ended boredom, and numbed fear.

Then, at 28, he woke up for the second morning in a row soaked in whiskey-tinged vomit, and he saw his life clearly. He would lose his job, then his relationships, then his life. Whether he died at 35, 55, or 75, drinking would end him early. Comfort wasn’t only numbing him to the life he wanted. It was killing him. “No one gets sober on a Friday evening,” he writes. “It’s a Sunday-morning-coming-down kind of a decision.” He quit. Drying out was miserable, but day by day, the world opened up.

Sober, he noticed he was still marinating in comfort, from his soft bed to his phone to his overstuffed sofa. So he began to wonder what cleansing himself of all those other comforts might do for him.

0.004 Percent

Humans evolved to seek comfort. For most of history, comforts were rare, so grabbing every bit of warmth, food, and rest helped you survive. Your world has changed, but your wiring hasn’t. The cars, climate control, smartphones, and ultraprocessed food that shape your day have been around for about 100 years. That’s 0.004 percent of the 2.5 million years that humans and their ancestors have walked the earth. Constant comfort is a radically new thing for humans.

Your ancestors were exposed to the weather; Americans now spend about 93 percent of their time indoors. They were often bored, until June 29, 2007, when boredom was pronounced dead, thanks to the iPhone. And they worked hard. The Hadza, hunter-gatherers in Tanzania who live much like the earliest humans, exercise 14 times more than the average American.

People now live longer than ever. But life span is up while health span is down. About 70 percent of Americans are overweight or obese, and depression, addiction, and suicide are rising. So if life is so much easier, why doesn’t it feel that way?

800 Faces

A Harvard psychologist named David Levari found one answer. He showed people 800 faces and asked which ones looked threatening. Partway through, he quietly began showing fewer and fewer threatening faces. Instead of relaxing, people started seeing neutral faces as threats. As you face fewer problems, you don’t become more satisfied. You just lower your bar for what counts as a problem. There is, quite literally, a scientific basis for first-world problems.

Comfort works the same way. When a new comfort arrives, you adapt to it, and the old one starts to feel unacceptable. Today’s comfort is tomorrow’s discomfort. Why take the stairs once there’s an escalator? Each new comfort shrinks your comfort zone, and it all happens without your noticing. Call it comfort creep. So what happens when you step far enough outside it to notice?

20 Yards

Easter first found out in 2017, on an elk hunt with Donnie in the mountains of Nevada. Donnie hunts only older animals, which keeps a herd healthy. “If you want to have amazing experiences,” he said, “you have to put yourself in amazing places.”

The discomfort started right away. A 72-degree lifestyle hadn’t prepared Easter for any other temperature. He shivered in every layer he’d packed while William, Donnie’s cameraman, stood around in a T-shirt. For days, the men climbed with 60-pound packs and sat for hours scanning empty ridges. Easter was cold, starving, and bored.

Then a bull elk the size of a pickup truck appeared. The men crept to a boulder just 20 yards away, and as Donnie drew his bow, Easter found a kind of presence that Zen monks meditate for decades to reach. A coyote spooked the elk, and it galloped off. “He was big and beautiful, but he was too young,” Donnie said. Walking back to camp, Easter felt more alive than he had since he first got sober. His mind was quieter, and his body felt abler.

50/50

A Harvard-trained doctor named Marcus Elliott had a name for that feeling: misogi. The word comes from a Japanese myth about a god who purified himself in a freezing river. Elliott runs a sports science lab that trains NBA stars, and once a year, he takes on one epic challenge in nature. His group once carried an 85-pound rock five kilometers along the ocean floor.

“Let’s say your potential is this big circle,” Elliott said, sweeping his arm wide. Then he drew a dinner-plate-size circle in the middle of it. “Well, most of us live in this small space right here. We have no idea what exists on the edges of our potential.”

Misogi has two rules. First, it has to be really hard: about a 50/50 chance of success, if you do everything right. If you’ve never run more than ten miles, a 25-mile trail run might qualify. Second, you can’t die. Elliott adds two softer guidelines. Make it quirky, so you can’t compare it to anyone else’s. Misogi is you against you. And don’t post about it. “I’m going to want to quit,” Elliott said. “But I’m not going to quit because I’m watching.”

Your brain hates this. For most of history, failing could mean dying, so you still overestimate what failure costs. Today, failure usually means you botch a PowerPoint. Taking on a task you might fail, even if you do everything right, is how you lose the fear of failing and find out what you can do. A psychologist named Mark Seery found the proof. In a study of 2,500 Americans, people who’d faced some adversity, not a lot but not zero, were happier and healthier than people who’d been sheltered their whole lives.

50, 70, or 90

Elliott made Easter want a misogi of his own. So when Donnie invited him to spend a month hunting caribou in the Arctic, he said yes. How much more dangerous than Nevada would it be? “Twenty times,” Donnie said. Easter joked that he’d been afraid Donnie would say fifty. “Well, it might be fifty,” Donnie said. “Could be seventy… or ninety.”

Easter had six months to turn a long shot into a coin flip. He took a wilderness medicine course, which covered broken bones but not grizzly attacks. “But you do now know how to dress gaping wounds!” the instructor told him. He wore a 40- to 60-pound pack while he vacuumed. And he found out he was bad at new things, which was part of the gift. Doing the same things over and over puts your brain on autopilot, and the days blur. Newness forces you into the present, and it can even slow down your sense of time.

On the morning he left, his wife dropped him at the airport with a hug and a suggestion: “Don’t get your head slapped off by a grizzly bear.”

150 People

“As our airplanes get smaller, our adventure gets bigger,” Donnie said. Most people now live far from the wild. Today, 84 percent of Americans live in cities, but only 12 percent say they want to, and city dwellers are 39 percent more likely to be depressed.

Part of the reason may be the number 150. Hunter-gatherer bands, ancient villages, and Roman legions all averaged around 150 people, and so does the personal network of the average American. Humans seem wired for groups that size, and crowds wear on us. In a Harvard ranking of the happiest American cities, New York came in dead last: 318th out of 318. Easter was about to get as far from a crowd as a person can get.

101 Miles

As Mike’s little Cessna climbed into the Arctic, Easter’s fear of flying vanished. Fear, he realized, is often something you feel before the experience. They bounced down on a patch of tundra 101 miles from the nearest town. Brian’s tiny plane could take only one passenger to camp at a time, and he took William first. That left Easter alone with a pile of grizzly scat and no gun.

People today are rarely alone, yet nearly half of Americans say they’re lonely. Yet the capacity to be alone may matter as much as good relationships, and most people are bad at it. In one study, a quarter of women and two-thirds of men chose to give themselves electric shocks rather than sit alone with their thoughts. “I think a goal we should all have,” said the psychologist Matthew Bowker, “is to try to transform feelings of loneliness into feelings of rich solitude.”

Standing on the tundra, Easter went from anxious to unencumbered. It was stress, but of a different type. A freeing stress.

Less Than 70 Miles an Hour

“The rules for surviving in the wild are shelter first, water second, food last,” Donnie said. The men pitched their teepee on a high ridge. At 2 a.m., the wind shifted. “It should hold in this,” Donnie said. By 5 a.m., gusts topped 70 miles an hour. “We’re asking too much of this thing,” he yelled. The men sat fully dressed in the dark, waiting to see if their shelter would hold. When they finally pulled out the center pole, they found the wind had driven it straight through the rock beneath it.

Everyone worries about bears, Donnie said later, but weather is what will kill you. Then he got serious. “Moments like that… you might find that they make everything else more colorful and more manageable.”

Part Two

Get Bored, Get Outside, Get Quiet

11 Hours, 6 Minutes

The average person spends 11 hours and 6 minutes a day on digital media. In the Arctic, Easter got none. The caribou didn’t show, so the men sat on hillsides for hours, scanning the land. Easter read his energy bar wrappers, planned his Christmas shopping, and did more push-ups than he had all year. He was deeply bored.

Boredom has a job. The neuroscientist James Danckert explains it with two cavemen picking berries. As one bush runs low, the caveman who can get bored moves on to fresh bushes, and by evening he has his berries plus time to spear dinner. The caveman who can’t get bored picks one bush clean and goes home with only berries. Boredom is a signal to do something. “But boredom is neither good nor bad,” Danckert said. “How you respond to it is what can make it good or bad.”

Today, most people answer that signal with a screen. The trigger is boredom, the behavior is checking your phone, and the reward is a hit of dopamine. That’s why the psychiatrist Judson Brewer calls phones “the slot machines in our pockets.” Your brain needs unfocused, mind-wandering time to rest, the way a muscle needs rest between sets. Every time you kill boredom with a screen, you add another rep, and overworked minds are linked to depression.

Let your mind wander instead. In one study, people who read a phone book for 15 minutes came up with more and better ideas afterward than people who weren’t bored. On a long walk back to camp one evening, Easter noticed new ideas bubbling up, and a fresh gratitude for home. Maybe the answer, he thought, isn’t “less phone.” Maybe it’s “more boredom.”

20 Minutes, 5 Hours, 3 Days

Near camp one evening, William crept toward a herd of caribou to film them. One spooked, and the whole herd stampeded straight toward Donnie and Easter. A hundred yards. Fifty. Thirty-five. The ground shook. Then the herd swept uphill, antlers black against a gold sunset. It was as wild as a religious experience.

Most people rarely get anything like it. More than half of Americans don’t go outside for fun at all. Yet nature now comes with doses. The nature researcher Rachel Hopman lays them out as a pyramid.

The base is 20 minutes in everyday nature, like a city park, three times a week. A 20-minute park walk leaves people calmer and sharper. “But,” Hopman said, “we found that people who used their cellphone on the walk saw none of those benefits.” The middle is about five hours a month in wilder places, like a hike or a fishing trip. The wilder the nature, the better.

The top is the three-day effect. On day one in the backcountry, you’re still thinking about work. By day two, you start to notice the sights, smells, and sounds around you. By day three, your senses are dialed in, and the discomfort starts to feel like calm. Backpackers who took a creativity test after three days in the wild without phones scored 50 percent better than those who took it before. “That’s why taking a backcountry trip each year is so important,” Hopman said.

12 Places

On the morning of day six, Easter climbed above camp and listened. After a while, he could hear his own heartbeat. Then a raven flew overhead, and in all that silence, its wings sounded like a helicopter. Birds’ wings make that sound everywhere. You just can’t hear it over the noise.

Humans have made the world four times louder. For most of history, a loud noise meant danger, so your body still answers noise with stress hormones. And you don’t notice the cost. Office workers in a loud open office said they felt no more stressed than workers in a quiet one, but their bodies pumped out more adrenaline, and they got less done.

One acoustic ecologist believes there are only 12 places in the Lower 48 where you can sit for 15 minutes without hearing a single human-made sound. But you don’t need to find one. A park calms people right away, and so does shutting off your devices. Two minutes of silence relaxed people more than a handful of other relaxation techniques.

Back at the teepee, Donnie asked what he’d been doing out there. “Just listening,” Easter said. “Listening to the silence.” “It’s wild, right?” Donnie said. “The silence alone is worth the price of admission.”

Part Three

Feel Hunger

Minus 4,000 Calories

“We’re getting into the lean times, boys!” William declared, cinching his belt. The men were eating about 2,000 calories a day and burning about 6,000. That put them 4,000 calories in the hole, every day. Even freeze-dried lasagna started to taste good. Hunger, it turns out, is the best sauce.

Back home, Easter had rarely felt real hunger. He ate because it was mealtime, or because he was stressed or bored. Studies show that real hunger now drives just 20 percent of eating. The rest is what the nutrition coach Trevor Kashey calls reward hunger: eating for comfort, not fuel. It’s also why diets fail. All diets work until about five weeks in. That’s when your brain makes you hungrier. People don’t lack information. They lack the ability to persist against the discomfort of hunger.

Kashey’s methods are simple. First, weigh and track what you eat. When Easter weighed his daily peanut butter, his one serving turned out to be three. Second, ask why you’re eating. Easter kept raiding the pantry when he got home on Fridays. Kashey gave him no rule, just a question: “What happens on Friday?” Easter was using food to unload the week’s stress. “People who are at a consistently healthy weight don’t have better genetics or a higher metabolism,” Kashey said. “They’re just more likely to deal with stress by, like, going for a walk instead of eating.”

Third, eat filling food. No food is off-limits, but you’d have to eat about seven croissants to feel as full as you would after one plain potato. So Kashey’s plate is a quarter animal protein, a quarter whole grains or potatoes, and half vegetables or fruit. With his help, Easter lost 15 pounds. Still, Kashey said, there’s one old kind of stress modern people almost never face: “Stress from lean times.”

12 to 16 Hours

It takes your body 12 to 16 hours to fully burn through your last meal. After that, it starts clearing out old, damaged cells, the kind linked to aging and disease. One researcher calls it your body “taking out the trash.” It’s a picture of what discomfort does to everything: your weak links are painfully sacrificed for your good.

Most people never get there. Humans evolved with feast and famine. Now there are just two settings: kind of feasting and definitely feasting. Early humans likely ate one or two meals a day. The average person now eats across a 15-hour window.

Hunger also sharpens you. “Think about a hungry wolf versus a lion who just ate,” said Dr. Jason Fung. “Which one is more focused? The hungry wolf.” The simplest way back to hunger is skipping breakfast, which gives your body its 12 to 16 hours. And remember, much of your hunger isn’t real. It’s a cheap way to comfort yourself against the discomforts of modern life.

Out on the tundra, Easter quit fighting the cold and the hunger. A line from his recovery helped: “And acceptance is the answer to all my problems today.” Hiking back to camp, he was hungry. Not just for food. For life.

Part Four

Think About Your Death Every Day

3 Good Legs

The men moved camp 20 miles north. Easter hadn’t planned to hunt. But Donnie believed hunting would show him how far modern people are from the cycle of life. “It’s an unbelievably big decision,” Donnie said. “But I do think you’d grasp why we’re out here better if you were to hunt.” So before the trip, Easter had trained with a rifleman until he could hit targets 1,000 yards away.

Then a herd came over a ridge toward them. The men belly-crawled through frost and mud, and Donnie picked out an old bull limping on a rear leg. “That’s your bull,” he said. “He’s old. Old.” When the herd was 100 yards away, Donnie gave him a choice. “If you don’t want to take the shot you shouldn’t. But if you’re going to take the shot you need to take it soon.”

The herd kept drifting. Finally the old bull stepped clear of the others and raised its head. Easter slowly let out his breath and settled the crosshairs just above the bull’s front shoulder.

12/31, 11:59:33 p.m.

The book leaves Easter there, finger on the trigger, and cuts to a blunt piece of advice: think about your death every day. Sober about 18 months, Easter heard a podcast describe the cosmic calendar, which squeezes the universe’s 13.8 billion years into one year. On it, all of recorded human history shows up on December 31, at about 11:59 and 33 seconds p.m. He felt so small, and so sure that he and everyone he loved would soon die and be forgotten, that he broke down sobbing in his pickup.

Eight in ten Westerners say death makes them uncomfortable. But facing it seems to help. In Bhutan, a small Himalayan kingdom, people are taught to think about death one to three times a day. The country ranks low in development, yet it’s among the 20 happiest on earth. So Easter flew there to learn why.

A Buddhist teacher told him Americans treat life like a checklist: a good spouse, a good house, a promotion, then a better house. “If you have ten pairs of shoes you want eleven pairs,” he said. Imagine walking a trail toward a cliff, he went on. The cliff is death, and everyone walks off it. “Don’t you want to know that there’s a cliff?” Only then can you take the scenic route, notice the beauty, and say what you truly want to say to the people walking with you.

A lama who counsels the dying told him the people with the most regrets are the ones who never thought about death. The key is mitakpa, or impermanence. “You must think of mitakpa three times each day,” the lama said. “Once in the morning, once in the afternoon, and once in the evening.” Research agrees that thinking about death makes people more grateful and more generous. As they said goodbye, the lama added, “Remember, death can come at any time. Any time.”

20 Minutes, 11 Seconds

Back on the tundra, Easter pulled the trigger, then fired again. The second shot cut through the bull’s heart and killed it instantly. He sat beside the caribou with a hand on its head. Its body held stories: a scar on its leg, hooves worn from hundreds of thousands of miles, teeth ground flat from years of grazing. He felt sadness and elation at once. Almost like love. “It’s heavy every single time,” Donnie told him. “If it’s ever not, then I’ll stop hunting.” In the wild, he added, old caribou are eaten alive by wolves or grizzlies, or they starve, drown, or get gored. “Nature can be brutal.”

In Bhutan, Easter had seen the lama’s warning come true. A few days after their talk, he hiked to Tiger’s Nest, a monastery clinging to a cliff. On his way out, he found a monk collapsed on a stone stairway. Easter started CPR while a doctor kept time, but no helicopter could land among the cliffs. “Twenty minutes, eleven seconds,” the doctor finally said. “You can stop.” Minutes earlier, the monk had been hiking and laughing with friends. Death can come at any time.

Part Five

Carry the Load

100+ Pounds

Back in Alaska, there was still the meat to carry. “The hunter should pack out the heaviest load,” Donnie said. “And he always carries the head.” Each pack weighed 90 to 110 pounds, and camp was five miles away, nearly all uphill. Easter’s legs burned, the straps cut into his shoulders, and there was no way out. He couldn’t duck into a 7-Eleven for a Snickers and a Slurpee. He remembered Elliott’s words: “In misogi you’ll reach this edge where you are convinced you have nothing left. But you’ll keep going anyway.”

Your brain resists effort because, for most of history, calories were precious. Research suggests that the fatigue you feel during exercise is mostly a protective emotion. Your brain hits the brakes well before your body reaches its real limit.

For most of history, humans were essentially professional athletes. Hunter-gatherers often covered more than 25 miles in a day. You’d call that a marathon. They called it picking up dinner. Today only 20 percent of Americans meet the national exercise guidelines, and just 2 percent take the stairs when there’s an escalator.

50 Pounds or Less

Your ancestors started walking on two feet about 4.4 million years ago, and the ability to carry things was a big reason why. The Harvard anthropologist Dan Lieberman calls humans “athletically pathetic.” You can’t outrun a grizzly, but you can go far, and a body built to go far is also built to carry far.

One modern tribe never stopped carrying: soldiers. Jason McCarthy, a former Green Beret who founded a company called GORUCK, walked Easter five miles to the company’s office, each of them with a 45-pound steel plate in a pack. Rucking just means walking with a weighted pack. “It’s cardio for the person who hates running, and strength work for the person who hates lifting,” McCarthy said. It burns two to three times the calories of walking and causes far fewer injuries than running.

The payoff of getting fit is huge. Being unfit may take as many as 23 years off your life. Smoking takes about 10. How heavy should you go? Military research found that 50 pounds is the heaviest load that lets soldiers move fast and stay safe, and people who weigh less than 150 pounds may want to carry less. Because everyone picks their own weight, rucking is social. “I ruck with my mom all the time,” McCarthy said. “She takes ten pounds. I take fifty. We go the same speed but get the same effect.” “Do hard things and the rest of life gets easier and you appreciate it all the more,” he said.

80 Percent

After five uphill miles, Easter reached camp and collapsed into the moss as it started to snow. Forget runner’s high. This was carrier’s high. That night the men seared caribou steaks with an onion Donnie had carried all those miles. It was better than any meat Easter had ever tasted.

He was worn out, but nothing hurt. The Arctic had pushed him back into the ways humans evolved to move: squatting, crawling, carrying, and sitting on hard ground. Modern life has engineered that away, and the result is pain. About 80 percent of Americans will have back pain at some point, and most of it seems to come from the way people now live.

The fix isn’t a hard gym session after a day in a chair. People who sit all day and then attack the gym have more back problems than couch potatoes. The better recipe, says the spine expert Stuart McGill, is gentle movement all day long: squat, lunge, hinge, hang, twist, bend, and carry. Carrying makes you stand tall and lock in the muscles that protect your spine.

The next morning, Donnie told him that guides often see clients who train in the gym all year and quit on the first or second day. “This experience can’t be replicated in a gym,” he said. Then William announced they needed more water, and the work went on.

81.2 Years

The men hunted for another couple of weeks. Before a storm forced them out, they saw a full migration, thousands of caribou converging at once. “I’ve been to Alaska for months at a time for nearly thirty years in a row,” Donnie said. “And I’ve never seen anything like this. Awe is the only word for it.”

In his Anchorage hotel, Easter stood in a long, scorching shower, scrubbing off a month of dirt. That may have done more harm than good. The Hadza live and eat in the dirt and rarely wash, yet they don’t seem to get Crohn’s, colitis, or colon cancer. “We sterilize everything,” said the anthropologist Stephanie Schnorr. “And here we are, more sick, fragile, and depleted.” The warmth is worth rethinking too. Women divers in Japan and Korea who work in cold water without wetsuits burn about 1,000 extra calories a day and get sick less often. In winter, scientists suggest lowering your thermostat three to four degrees a week until you’re living at about 64 degrees.

Hardship may even shape a whole people. Icelandic men live about 81.2 years, longer than men anywhere else. One Icelandic geneticist believes 1,100 years on “this merciless little island” made his people harder to kill.

Back home, Easter asked his wife if he’d changed. “I think so,” she said. “Since you’ve got back you’re almost impossible to rattle.” He noticed more and thought less. He sought out silence, solitude, and connection, spent less time on screens, and rucked in the desert twice a week. Chasing what makes humans harder to kill was making it easier for him to live. But comfort creep gains a few inches every day, so he’s already planning his next misogi.

You don’t need 33 days in the Arctic to start. Let yourself get bored. Walk outside without your phone, 20 minutes at a time. Sit in silence. Feel real hunger, and give your body 12 to 16 hours without food. Think about the cliff ahead. Carry something heavy. And once a year, try something you only have a fifty-fifty chance of finishing. Comfort will keep creeping in. Choosing a little discomfort on purpose is how you push back, and how you get to live more of your “one wild and precious life.”

Questions

What The Comfort Crisis is about

Michael Easter’s The Comfort Crisis (Rodale, 2021) argues that modern life has stripped out the hardships humans evolved with, and that people need some of them back. Easter notes that life span is up while health span is down, and that each new comfort soon feels normal, a slide Easter calls comfort creep. A health journalist who quit drinking at 28, Easter sets the research between scenes from a 33-day caribou hunt in the Arctic. Easter’s fixes: a yearly misogi, boredom, the 20-5-3 dose of nature, silence, real hunger, a daily thought of death and rucking.

Who should read it

Anyone whose life is easy but who feels soft, restless or flat: the desk worker who is never cold or hungry, the person who reaches for a phone at every pause, the gym regular who wants a challenge with real stakes. It suits readers who like adventure stories with their science, and most of its fixes, like a 20-minute walk without a phone, fit an ordinary week. Readers who dislike hunting should know that the book’s story is a caribou hunt, and Easter kills an old bull.

Questions people ask

What is a misogi in The Comfort Crisis?

One very hard challenge in nature, taken on once a year. In The Comfort Crisis, Michael Easter learns the idea from Marcus Elliott, a Harvard-trained doctor who runs a sports science lab that trains NBA stars. The word comes from a Japanese myth about a god who purified himself in a freezing river. A misogi has two rules: it must be so hard that you have about a 50/50 chance of success if you do everything right, and you can’t die. Elliott adds two guidelines: make it quirky, so you can’t compare it with anyone else’s, and don’t post about it. Easter’s own misogi was a 33-day caribou hunt in the Arctic.

What is comfort creep, according to Michael Easter?

It is the way each new comfort soon feels normal, so the old level starts to feel unacceptable. In The Comfort Crisis, Michael Easter sums it up as “today’s comfort is tomorrow’s discomfort”: once there is an escalator, why take the stairs? Each comfort shrinks your comfort zone, and you don’t notice. Easter ties it to a 2018 Science study by the Harvard psychologist David Levari and colleagues. When threatening faces became rare, people began to see neutral faces as threats. As you face fewer problems, Easter writes, you don’t become more satisfied. You just lower your bar for what counts as a problem.

What is the 20-5-3 rule for nature in The Comfort Crisis?

It is a dose of nature: 20 minutes three times a week, five hours a month and three days a year. In The Comfort Crisis, Michael Easter takes it from the nature researcher Rachel Hopman, who lays it out as a pyramid. The base is 20 minutes in everyday nature, like a city park, which leaves people calmer and sharper unless they use their phones. The middle is about five hours a month somewhere wilder, like a hike or a fishing trip. The top is the three-day effect: backpackers who took a creativity test after three days in the wild without phones scored 50 percent better than those who took it before. A 2012 PLOS ONE study of 56 hikers, tested on day four, found that gain.

Is boredom good for you, according to The Comfort Crisis?

It can be. In The Comfort Crisis, the neuroscientist James Danckert tells Michael Easter that boredom “is neither good nor bad,” and that “how you respond to it is what can make it good or bad.” Boredom is a signal to do something: the caveman who got bored of a picked-over berry bush moved on and still had time to spear dinner. Today most people answer that signal with a screen, so the mind gets little chance to wander and rest. In one study Easter cites, people who read a phone book for 15 minutes came up with more and better ideas afterward than people who had not been bored. So the answer, Easter thought, may not be “less phone” but “more boredom.”

What does The Comfort Crisis say about hunger and fasting?

That real hunger is good for you, and that much eating is not hunger at all. In The Comfort Crisis, Michael Easter takes the term reward hunger from the nutrition coach Trevor Kashey: eating for comfort, not fuel. Easter says diets fail because people can’t persist against the discomfort of hunger. Easter also says the body starts clearing out old, damaged cells after 12 to 16 hours without food, and that skipping breakfast is the simplest way to get there. Cleveland Clinic says this cleanup, called autophagy, may begin at 24 to 48 hours of fasting in animal studies. It adds that there is not enough research on its timing in people.

Why does The Comfort Crisis say to think about your death every day?

Because, the book says, thinking about death makes people more grateful and more generous. In The Comfort Crisis, Michael Easter flew to Bhutan, where people are taught to think about death daily. A Buddhist teacher pictured life as a trail that ends at a cliff. If you know the cliff is there, you take the scenic route and say what you want to say to the people beside you. A lama who counsels the dying said the people with the most regrets never thought about death, and told Easter, “You must think of mitakpa three times each day.” Mitakpa means impermanence. Days later, Easter did CPR on a monk who collapsed near Tiger’s Nest. After 20 minutes and 11 seconds, a doctor said to stop.

How heavy should a ruck be, according to The Comfort Crisis?

At most about 50 pounds, and perhaps less for people under 150 pounds. In The Comfort Crisis, Michael Easter reports that military research found 50 pounds to be the heaviest load that lets soldiers move fast and stay safe. Rucking just means walking with a weighted pack. Easter learns it from Jason McCarthy, a former Green Beret who founded GORUCK, on a five-mile walk with a 45-pound plate in each pack. McCarthy calls it “cardio for the person who hates running, and strength work for the person who hates lifting.” Since each person picks a weight, it is social: McCarthy’s mother carries 10 pounds to McCarthy’s 50, at the same pace.

Is The Comfort Crisis worth reading?

Yes, for readers who like adventure writing mixed with science and want small, concrete ways to toughen up. Michael Easter’s The Comfort Crisis (Rodale, 2021) sets studies and interviews between scenes from a 33-day Arctic hunt, and shows how to get the same benefits at home in small doses. One fair criticism is that frame. Reviewing the book in 2024, the blog Man of la Book said the Alaska trip is one “only wealthy people with ample spare time can take,” noted that the team had a plane on call, and found the real value in the research Easter cites. The summary on this page follows the book chapter by chapter in about 22 minutes.

Put it into practice

The free tools on the Pursue Adventure shelf turn books like this one into steps you can take this week.

Summaries to read next

Ratey explains what chosen stress does inside the brain: neurons, like muscles, grow more resilient when stressed. Among Ratey’s mild stresses to bring on yourself are exercise and eating less, and exercise helps because you choose it and control it. Read our summary of Spark by John Ratey.

Brooks cites the same finding as Easter: two-thirds of men and a quarter of women chose electric shocks over sitting alone with their thoughts. Brooks’s advice is close to Easter’s: get bored on purpose and treat boredom like the gym, uncomfortable at first, then something you come to like. Read our summary of The Meaning of Your Life by Arthur C. Brooks.

Comer makes a case like Easter’s for silence, solitude and the idle moments the phone has taken, from the life of Jesus, who often withdrew to lonely places to pray. Comer calls those moments “potential portals to prayer,” and writes, “Solitude is engagement; isolation is escape.” Read our summary of The Ruthless Elimination of Hurry by John Mark Comer.

Sources

Facts last checked October 2026.