What's Broken?
Pick the symptom that fits and get dealt a 5–8 card reading list — drawn from across the five parts of every business, in the order Kaufman would have you read them. The diagnostic doesn't tell you the answer. It tells you which models to think with.
I'm not sure what to build
Start at the customer β what drive, what end-result, what form of value β then test the riskiest assumption before you build anything else.
-
Every successful offer satisfies at least one of these β often more. The clearer you are about which drive your product hits, the easier the rest of the business gets. Vague "value props" usually map to none of the five; sharp ones map to two or three at once.
ExampleA premium gym sells defend (health) + bond (community) + feel (identity), not "fitness."
Use this whenYou can't finish the sentence "people buy this because they want to ___."
-
People buy quarter-inch holes, not quarter-inch drills. They buy a confident toast at the wedding, not the public-speaking course. Until you can describe the end-result in their words, your offer is competing on features instead of outcomes β and features lose to outcomes every time.
ExampleTurbotax sells "your taxes are done and you can stop dreading the mail" β not "tax software."
Use this whenYour messaging keeps listing features instead of outcomes.
-
Most struggling businesses are stuck in one form when bundling or unbundling would serve customers better. A consultant (service) trapped on the hourly treadmill might unlock real leverage by turning their playbook into a product, a subscription, or a shared resource.
ExampleA yoga teacher offering classes (service) + a recorded library (product) + a membership (subscription) + retreats (audience aggregation) is four forms in one.
Use this whenYou're hitting a ceiling in your current form and can't see why.
-
Most plans collapse under one or two specific assumptions β not a hundred small ones. Write them down. Rank them by "how badly does this hurt if I'm wrong?" Then design the cheapest possible experiment to test the most dangerous one first. Don't waste cycles testing things that don't matter.
Example"Parents will pay $40/month for this app" is critical. "Users prefer green to blue" is not.
Use this whenYour plan has many moving parts and you don't know which to test first.
-
The single signal you can get no other way is whether people will actually pull out a wallet. Pre-orders, deposits, paid waitlists, smoke-test landing pages β anything that converts attention into intent before you build the thing β is more valuable than any survey. The most expensive mistake in business is building something nobody wants.
ExampleFitbit raised $2 million on pre-orders before shipping a single device.
Use this whenYou're about to spend significant time or money building something speculative.
-
Skipping the loop feels faster but raises risk dramatically. A few quick cycles teach you more about the market β and about which assumptions are actually load-bearing β than months of "thinking it through." Speed of iteration beats one-shot accuracy almost every time.
ExampleShipping an ugly landing page on Tuesday and reading the signups by Friday beats a polished launch in eight weeks.
Use this whenYou've been planning for more than two weeks without shipping anything.
-
A prototype is not a product β it's a question made tangible. Its only job is to surface what you couldn't learn any other way. The faster and uglier, the better. Polish before validation is the most common form of self-deception in early business.
ExampleA "service" delivered manually by you, behind the curtain, while the customer thinks it's software β the classic Wizard of Oz prototype.
Use this whenYou catch yourself perfecting an idea no real customer has seen yet.
People aren't paying attention
Narrow the target, sharpen the hook, borrow a trusted audience's attention, then earn permission to keep showing up.
-
Most marketing fails because it's aimed at "everyone." When you can describe your probable purchaser in concrete detail β their day, their language, where they already spend attention β every other marketing decision gets sharper and cheaper. Narrower targets cost less to reach and convert higher.
Example"Bookkeeping for Shopify sellers doing $200Kβ$2M" outperforms "small-business bookkeeping" on every metric.
Use this whenYou can't describe a single customer in concrete, specific detail.
-
The same offer falls flat or lands depending on context. A loan ad before payday lands. The same ad mid-paycheck doesn't. Reach matters less than reaching the right person at the right moment. Hunt for the moments your probable purchaser is already aware of the problem you solve.
ExampleMattress ads run heaviest after college acceptance letters go out, when moving is on the mind.
Use this whenYour message is fine but the conversion rate is flat.
-
Your hook is the one chance you have to convert a passing glance into a closer look. It should name a specific person, a specific outcome, and ideally a specific timeframe β all in plain language. If your hook fits on a t-shirt and a stranger nods at it, you have one. If it requires a paragraph of setup, you don't.
Example"Lose weight without giving up bread." Specific person, specific outcome, specific constraint.
Use this whenYou can't explain what you offer in one sentence to a friend at a bar.
-
Remarkable offers spread on their own. The bar isn't "good" β good things don't get talked about. The bar is unexpected, distinctive, worth-the-breath-it-takes-to-mention. If no one would casually bring it up at a dinner table, the marketing has to do all the work itself.
ExampleLiquid Death β water in a tallboy can β is a commodity made remarkable by packaging alone.
Use this whenYou're relying on paid acquisition because nothing about the offer spreads on its own.
-
Building an audience from scratch is slow. Allied audiences β partnerships, podcast appearances, joint launches with people whose followers overlap yours β compress years of permission-building into a single warm introduction. The price is usually splitting upside or reciprocating later.
ExampleA new author who co-hosts a webinar with an established author in the same niche taps thousands of pre-qualified readers in a single evening.
Use this whenYou have a great offer but no audience to put it in front of.
-
Permission is the most valuable asset in marketing. An email list of 1,000 people who opted in beats 100,000 strangers who didn't. Permission compounds: every message you send builds (or burns) it. The job of any first interaction is to earn enough trust to send a second one.
ExampleA newsletter with 800 engaged subscribers is worth more than 80,000 followers on a platform that controls reach.
Use this whenYour entire customer acquisition depends on a channel you don't own.
-
Free is a marketing strategy, not a business model. The trick is to give away something that produces real value on its own but obviously points toward the paid offer. Give away too little and no one tries it. Give away the whole thing and no one buys.
ExampleA consultant who publishes a free 12-page playbook gets booked by readers who realize they'd rather pay her than implement it themselves.
Use this whenYou need to build an audience but have no marketing budget.
People look but don't buy
Hunt the specific reasons willing buyers stall β risk, friction, unclear next step β and dissolve them one by one.
-
List them: confusion, perceived risk, friction in the checkout, lack of urgency, fear of choosing wrong, social hesitation. Each barrier you remove makes the offer measurably stronger without changing the offer itself. This is some of the highest-leverage work in any business.
ExampleAdding "Pay over 4 months, no fee" doubled conversion for one furniture brand β the offer never changed.
Use this whenTraffic is fine, interest seems real, but transactions are thin.
-
Most "no" decisions are not rejections of the offer β they're rejections of the risk of being wrong about the offer. Guarantees, trials, payment terms, pilots, and pay-on-results structures dissolve that risk. The stronger your guarantee, the more customers self-select into the deal.
Example"Try it for 30 days. If you don't use it, full refund β no questions." quietly doubles conversion on most info products.
Use this whenPeople are interested but stalling before they buy.
-
Every piece of marketing should ask for exactly one thing β and ask plainly. "Learn more" is weak. "Start the 7-day trial" is strong. Multiple CTAs split attention and reduce conversion on all of them. Default to the smallest possible commitment that still moves the person forward.
ExampleA landing page with one big "Get the first chapter free" button outperforms one with three competing buttons.
Use this whenYour traffic is fine but conversion is poor.
-
Cost-plus pricing leaves enormous money on the table for offers that produce real outcomes. If your work helps a customer make or save $50,000, charging $500 because "that's a fair hourly rate" is a gift you can't afford. Anchor on the value to them; let your costs disappear into the conversation.
ExampleA consultant who saves a client $1M of tax can defensibly charge $50K β twenty times what the same hours would bill at "rate."
Use this whenYou're pricing by hours, materials, or comparison to commodities.
-
Trust closes every sale. It compounds with each promise kept and breaks instantly with each one broken. The fastest accelerator of trust is the testimony of someone the buyer already trusts. The slowest destroyer of it is your own track record β but the slowest is also the most reliable.
ExampleA new contractor who shows up exactly on time for the bid wins more jobs before saying a word about price.
Use this whenCustomers like you but won't commit.
-
When you educate honestly, you position yourself as the expert and let the offer sell itself. The customer arrives at the buying decision having thought it through with you, instead of being pushed. This is the marketing of choice for high-trust, considered purchases.
ExampleA financial advisor who runs a free retirement-math workshop sells more accounts than one who runs an ad.
Use this whenYour offer requires the customer to first realize they have a problem.
I think I'm undercharging
Re-price against value (not cost), test upward, and notice how much pricing power your differentiation has actually earned.
-
Most people use one method (usually market comparison) and miss huge pricing surface. Run your offer through all four. The right price is usually the highest defensible answer. The widest gap between the four numbers is where the most pricing power hides.
ExampleA software tool: $50/mo by market comparison, $400/mo by value comparison to the manual work it replaces. The honest price is somewhere in between β but a lot closer to $400 than $50.
Use this whenYou picked your price by gut, by competitor lookups, or by what feels fair.
-
Cost-plus pricing leaves enormous money on the table for offers that produce real outcomes. If your work helps a customer make or save $50,000, charging $500 because "that's a fair hourly rate" is a gift you can't afford. Anchor on the value to them; let your costs disappear into the conversation.
ExampleA consultant who saves a client $1M of tax can defensibly charge $50K β twenty times what the same hours would bill at "rate."
Use this whenYou're pricing by hours, materials, or comparison to commodities.
-
Pricing power comes from a combination of differentiation, switching cost, scarcity, and how badly the customer needs the result. The best businesses build pricing power deliberately over time β through reputation, lock-in, and irreplaceability β instead of competing on price.
ExampleA coach who is the obvious choice for one specific kind of client can raise prices yearly without losing demand.
Use this whenRaising prices feels terrifying, which usually means they're overdue.
-
There's no objectively correct price. There's only the price at which you make the most money you're comfortable making, given who you serve. Treat price as an experiment, not a setting. Most prices are too low; many are 2β3x too low.
ExampleRaising prices 25% and losing 10% of customers usually means more revenue and less work β a strict win.
Use this whenYou've had the same price for more than 12 months.
-
People will pay handsomely to eliminate confusion, complexity, wasted time, and effort. The most valuable offers reduce end-user involvement as much as possible while satisfying a core human drive. Hassles other people have learned to tolerate are usually invisible to them β and obvious to you.
ExampleStripe charges a premium over older payment processors because its API removed a week of integration hassle.
Use this whenYou're searching for a problem worth solving in a market you already know.
-
People buy quarter-inch holes, not quarter-inch drills. They buy a confident toast at the wedding, not the public-speaking course. Until you can describe the end-result in their words, your offer is competing on features instead of outcomes β and features lose to outcomes every time.
ExampleTurbotax sells "your taxes are done and you can stop dreading the mail" β not "tax software."
Use this whenYour messaging keeps listing features instead of outcomes.
Delivery is messy or inconsistent
Predictability beats peak quality β define the process, manage expectations, remove friction the customer feels but you don't.
-
Without a process, every delivery is a small reinvention β slow, expensive, and uneven. Write the steps down. Run them. Improve the steps, not the people. A bad process beats no process; a documented process beats undocumented heroics.
ExampleA four-step onboarding checklist turns "we forgot to send the welcome packet again" into a non-issue.
Use this whenThe same mistakes keep happening to different customers.
-
Predictability often matters more than peak quality. A consistent 7 beats an inconsistent 9. Predictability is what lets customers recommend you with confidence and lets you raise prices without nerves. It's built by process, not by talent.
ExampleStarbucks is rarely the best coffee in town. It's reliably the same coffee in every town β and that's the business.
Use this whenYour average is fine but variance is killing referrals.
-
Quality is a relationship between expectation and delivery β not an absolute. A $5 burger and a $50 burger can both be "high quality" if both meet their expectations. Quality problems are almost always expectation-management problems in disguise.
ExampleBudget airlines aren't low quality. They're high quality at delivering exactly what they promised: cheap, on time, no frills.
Use this whenCustomers seem disappointed even though you delivered what you offered.
-
Promise less and deliver more, and ordinary work feels like a gift. Promise more and deliver the same, and that same work feels like a letdown. Expectation-setting is a quality lever the customer never sees you pull.
ExampleDisney quotes wait times that are pessimistically long. Coming out 12 minutes early feels like delight, not deception.
Use this whenCustomers seem fine on the work itself but unhappy with the experience.
-
The owner-trapped business has no systems β only an owner. Systemization is the bridge from "I do everything" to "the work happens without me." Every process you systemize is a piece of your time you buy back permanently.
ExampleA solopreneur who writes a 6-page operations doc can hire a part-time VA for $20/hour to reclaim 15 hours a week.
Use this whenYou're the bottleneck and you can't take a week off without things falling apart.
-
Friction is invisible to insiders and enormous to newcomers. Login pages, confusing menus, mandatory training, unanswered emails β each is a small tax on the experience. Hunt friction the way you'd hunt costs.
Example1-Click ordering wasn't a feature. It was the removal of friction. It was also worth billions.
Use this whenCustomer feedback is full of "it took me a while to figure outβ¦"
-
Every confusing instruction, extra click, missing piece, or open question increases performance load and reduces the felt value of the offer. The job of delivery is not just to provide the thing β it's to make the thing easy to receive, easy to use, and easy to enjoy.
ExampleIKEA includes one Allen key and four labeled steps. The furniture is fine; the assembly is the actual product.
Use this whenCustomers stop using what they paid for soon after they bought it.
I'm busy but not profitable
Stop optimizing top-line revenue; start watching margin, cash, and what every dollar of spend is actually buying.
-
Revenue is vanity, profit is sanity, cash is reality. A business with high revenue and thin margin is one shock away from collapse. Healthy margin gives you the room to invest, weather slow seasons, and say no to bad customers. Defend it aggressively.
ExampleTwo consultants billing $300K/year: one keeps $200K, one keeps $30K. The first has a business; the second has an expensive hobby.
Use this whenYou're celebrating revenue without knowing the take-home number.
-
Profitable businesses go bankrupt every day because they ran out of cash before their invoices got paid. Cash flow is the heartbeat β track it weekly. Negative cash flow can be survived briefly; ignored cash flow ends the business.
ExampleA growing agency with $400K AR and $40K in the bank is one slow-paying client away from missing payroll.
Use this whenYou're uncertain whether next month's bills will clear without stress.
-
Without a clear sufficiency number, "more" is the default goal and you'll never feel like you have it. With one, you can make choices that "more" forbids: stop selling at a certain hour, turn down a bad client, take a sabbatical. Sufficiency is one of the most underrated financial models in business.
ExampleA solo operator decides $180K/year covers her life and savings goals. Above that, she optimizes for free time, not income.
Use this whenYou're working harder than you'd like and don't know why "enough" never arrives.
-
Every yes is a no to something else. The cost of any choice is not just the money β it's the alternative use of that money, that time, that attention. Operators who internalize this stop measuring "good ROI" and start measuring "best available ROI."
Example$20K in marketing spend isn't evaluated against zero. It's evaluated against what that $20K could have done as inventory, hiring, or a price test.
Use this whenYou're congratulating yourself for a "positive return" without asking what else was possible.
-
Without this number, marketing spend is a guess. With it, every channel becomes a math problem: does this channel cost less than my AAC? Anything below is scalable; anything above is a slow-motion bleed.
ExampleA SaaS with $40/month average revenue and 18-month lifetime = $720 LTV. With a 30% margin target, AAC is roughly $200.
Use this whenYou're spending on ads, content, or partnerships and can't say whether they're working.
-
Monthly reconciliation. Two-person sign-off on big spend. A bookkeeper. A simple dashboard. Internal controls feel boring until they save the business from a $30K mistake. Most early-stage operators skip them and pay the tuition later, usually in tax season.
ExampleA simple monthly subscription audit catches the $400/month tool no one's used in eight months.
Use this whenYou don't actually know exactly what your business is spending money on.
-
Burn rate sets the speed of every clock β runway, hiring, urgency. The lower it is, the more time you have to figure things out. Many businesses fail because they upgraded their lifestyle, office, or team before the revenue justified the new burn β and then revenue dipped.
ExampleA $40K/month burn with $20K/month revenue is a $20K monthly drain β fine for a quarter, fatal over a year.
Use this whenYou're adding fixed costs and haven't recomputed the runway in months.
I don't know if it's working
Name what would have to be true for this to be working β then build the smallest dashboard that tells you weekly.
-
Most plans collapse under one or two specific assumptions β not a hundred small ones. Write them down. Rank them by "how badly does this hurt if I'm wrong?" Then design the cheapest possible experiment to test the most dangerous one first. Don't waste cycles testing things that don't matter.
Example"Parents will pay $40/month for this app" is critical. "Users prefer green to blue" is not.
Use this whenYour plan has many moving parts and you don't know which to test first.
-
Skipping the loop feels faster but raises risk dramatically. A few quick cycles teach you more about the market β and about which assumptions are actually load-bearing β than months of "thinking it through." Speed of iteration beats one-shot accuracy almost every time.
ExampleShipping an ugly landing page on Tuesday and reading the signups by Friday beats a polished launch in eight weeks.
Use this whenYou've been planning for more than two weeks without shipping anything.
-
Monthly reconciliation. Two-person sign-off on big spend. A bookkeeper. A simple dashboard. Internal controls feel boring until they save the business from a $30K mistake. Most early-stage operators skip them and pay the tuition later, usually in tax season.
ExampleA simple monthly subscription audit catches the $400/month tool no one's used in eight months.
Use this whenYou don't actually know exactly what your business is spending money on.
-
LTV reframes every customer interaction. A "small" $30/month customer is actually a $1,080 customer if they stay 3 years. Decisions about service quality, refunds, and onboarding investment look entirely different when measured against LTV instead of first-transaction value.
ExampleA salon that spends $40 on a perfect first-visit experience for a $60 haircut looks foolish β unless you know the average client returns 18 times.
Use this whenYou're making service decisions based on the size of one transaction.
-
Without this number, marketing spend is a guess. With it, every channel becomes a math problem: does this channel cost less than my AAC? Anything below is scalable; anything above is a slow-motion bleed.
ExampleA SaaS with $40/month average revenue and 18-month lifetime = $720 LTV. With a 30% margin target, AAC is roughly $200.
Use this whenYou're spending on ads, content, or partnerships and can't say whether they're working.
-
Predictability often matters more than peak quality. A consistent 7 beats an inconsistent 9. Predictability is what lets customers recommend you with confidence and lets you raise prices without nerves. It's built by process, not by talent.
ExampleStarbucks is rarely the best coffee in town. It's reliably the same coffee in every town β and that's the business.
Use this whenYour average is fine but variance is killing referrals.
-
Revenue is vanity, profit is sanity, cash is reality. A business with high revenue and thin margin is one shock away from collapse. Healthy margin gives you the room to invest, weather slow seasons, and say no to bad customers. Defend it aggressively.
ExampleTwo consultants billing $300K/year: one keeps $200K, one keeps $30K. The first has a business; the second has an expensive hobby.
Use this whenYou're celebrating revenue without knowing the take-home number.
I'm stuck doing all of it myself
You don't have a business yet β you have a job with autonomy. Systemize one repeated task at a time until the work happens without you.
-
If the answer is one β usually the founder β the business has a fragility problem. Every critical task that lives only in one head is a single point of failure. The path to a real business runs through making yourself non-essential to specific functions, one by one.
ExampleA consulting firm where only the founder can deliver the flagship engagement has a bus factor of 1 β and a hard ceiling on revenue.
Use this whenYou think about taking real time off and immediately think about who would cover what.
-
The owner-trapped business has no systems β only an owner. Systemization is the bridge from "I do everything" to "the work happens without me." Every process you systemize is a piece of your time you buy back permanently.
ExampleA solopreneur who writes a 6-page operations doc can hire a part-time VA for $20/hour to reclaim 15 hours a week.
Use this whenYou're the bottleneck and you can't take a week off without things falling apart.
-
Without a process, every delivery is a small reinvention β slow, expensive, and uneven. Write the steps down. Run them. Improve the steps, not the people. A bad process beats no process; a documented process beats undocumented heroics.
ExampleA four-step onboarding checklist turns "we forgot to send the welcome packet again" into a non-issue.
Use this whenThe same mistakes keep happening to different customers.
-
The output of every great operator should eventually be a replicable system, not a one-of-a-kind performance. If only you can do it, you don't have a business β you have a job with autonomy. Replication is what turns expertise into an asset.
ExampleA surgeon-founder who writes a teachable protocol for a procedure that used to require him personally has multiplied the practice's value 10x.
Use this whenGrowth requires more of your personal hours.
-
Every confusing instruction, extra click, missing piece, or open question increases performance load and reduces the felt value of the offer. The job of delivery is not just to provide the thing β it's to make the thing easy to receive, easy to use, and easy to enjoy.
ExampleIKEA includes one Allen key and four labeled steps. The furniture is fine; the assembly is the actual product.
Use this whenCustomers stop using what they paid for soon after they bought it.
-
Modular offerings serve more customer types with less work. Each module can be improved on its own. New offers become recombinations, not from-scratch builds. This is how a single body of work expands into a product line without proportional effort.
ExampleA coach with six modular workshops can mix-and-match them into corporate trainings, a self-paced course, or a flagship retreat.
Use this whenYou keep custom-building new offers from scratch for similar customers.
-
Reframing dollars as employees changes every spending decision. A $5,000 expense isn't just $5,000 β it's an employee you just fired who would have produced returns for decades. This is the mental shift behind almost every wealthy operator.
Example$10K invested at 7% for 30 years becomes $76K. Spend the $10K and you spent $76K of future self.
Use this whenYou're weighing a discretionary purchase against an investment alternative.