Hearing God

Many sincere Christians hear others say that God spoke to them and quietly wonder why he never speaks to them. Willard argues that you were made for an ongoing conversation with God, and that his voice usually comes quietly, through your own thoughts. He shows how to recognize it, and what to do when God is silent.

Preface

Hearing God? To some people, that sounds bold, even risky. Who are you to say God talks to you? But what if you were made for it? Then the real risk is going through life without hearing him. You feel this most when a big decision comes. Your future feels heavy, and the second-guessing starts. Did you make the wise choice? Is it what God wanted? Is he still with you if you got it wrong?

God made you to be his close friend. And like any close friend, he will speak to you when there’s something to say. But hearing God is only one part of that friendship, and getting directions from him is only one part of hearing him. So there’s no trick or formula for finding out what God wants. Being in his will doesn’t even mean knowing what he prefers in every detail. The author, Dallas Willard, saw this with his own kids. When John and Becky were small, they often played happily in the backyard. He didn’t care which game they picked. Still, they were doing exactly what he wanted. You’re in God’s will the same way: whenever you’re living the kind of life he wants for you. That leaves plenty of room for your own choices.

And God wants more from you than following orders. Jesus told a story about a servant who plows a field all day, then comes inside and serves his master dinner. The master doesn’t thank him. The servant only did what he was told. God isn’t looking for a servant who only obeys. He’s looking for one who loves him, because the right kind of obedience grows out of love. What God really wants is to walk through life with you, talking together as you go. But that raises a puzzle.

A Paradox About Hearing God

Willard first ran into this puzzle as a young assistant pastor. One Sunday morning, the church’s pastor preached about plans for a new building. He told the congregation that God had spoken to him about what to do. That afternoon, Willard sat with his wife’s family around the table after Sunday dinner. His wife’s grandmother, whom everyone called Mema, was quiet and lost in thought. Finally she said softly, “I wonder why God never speaks to me like that.”

Willard never forgot that simple comment. Mema had rock-solid faith, and everyone knew how closely she walked with God. She didn’t lack a relationship with God. She just didn’t have the words for it. Willard saw how easy talk about God’s voice leaves many sincere Christians like her feeling left out. Until that day, he had simply assumed that every real Christian heard from God.

Still, he never stopped believing that you’re meant to live in an ongoing conversation with God. God walked with Adam and Eve, and he talked with Moses. Those stories show the normal life God intended for people. And many people today can describe a time they were sure God spoke to them. They just rarely talk about it.

Here’s one example. In 1973, Robert McFarlane was a new Christian living in Southern California. Three years earlier, he’d been forced to take over an insurance agency, and the stress never let up. One morning on his drive to work, he felt a desperate urge to take the road out of town and just disappear. Then a command came, almost as if it were written on his windshield: “Pull over to the curb.” He pulled over. Then words came, as if someone in the car were talking to him: “My Son had strains that you will never know, and when he had those strains he turned to me, and that’s what you should do.” He sat behind the wheel and sobbed. Then he drove to his office, where twenty-two major problems were waiting. By the end of the day, the biggest ones were mostly solved.

So here’s the paradox. The Bible, church history, and your own church leaders all say God speaks to people personally. The Holy Spirit who lives in you isn’t silent. He does more than give you an occasional nudge, a rush of warmth, or goose bumps. Yet almost no one can explain how hearing God actually works. So sincere people treat random events as signs from God and make terrible mistakes. Whole groups of people fall under leaders who claim God gave them a special message, because no one knows how to test it.

Wrong motives make it worse. Many people want to hear God only so they can feel safe about the future. Others want God to make their choices so they don’t have to take responsibility for them. But you aren’t a robot, and God doesn’t work with robots. He guides you the way a good parent does: by helping you grow into someone who can make good decisions on your own. At its root, failing to hear God means failing to grow into a real conversation with him, like two friends working on a project together. A few guidelines can help.

Guidelines for Hearing from God

Before you learn how to hear God, it helps to know what kind of relationship he wants with you. The movie The Stepford Wives makes the point well. In it, a couple moves to a suburb where almost every wife is strangely cheerful all the time. The wives get excited about clean floors, never argue, and have no opinions of their own. It turns out the town’s men’s club has replaced them with obedient robots. The movie makes a point that’s easy to forget. In a close relationship, perfect agreement is worthless if it’s mindless, or if it costs someone their freedom. God could have made a world of robots. But then there would be no conversation, only orders.

If you think prayer is just God telling you what to do, prayer stops mattering, and prayer meetings feel dead. Real prayer is an honest back-and-forth between you and God as you work on things together. So here’s the first guideline. Don’t make hearing God’s voice your main goal. Make your main goal growing into a mature person in a loving relationship with him. Someone who loves you doesn’t want to boss you around. They want you to understand what’s needed, so they don’t have to give orders. God isn’t the harsh master that the scared servant imagined in one of Jesus’ parables. That servant was so afraid that he buried the money his master gave him and simply handed it back later. He did nothing wrong. And doing nothing was the biggest wrong of all.

The second guideline: ordinary people really can talk with God. The prophet Elijah did mighty things through God’s power, then ran for his life, feeling sorry for himself. Yet the Bible calls him “a human being like us.” So when you read the Bible, assume the people in it felt what you would feel in their place. Picture yourself as Moses at the burning bush, or as young Samuel lying awake in his dark room. In the movie Gandhi, a minister jokes that he’s a man of God, but he doesn’t think God plans his day around him. That sounds humble. But God’s greatness is exactly what lets him plan his day around you.

Talking with God also takes humility. Moses was the humblest man on earth, and he may also hold the record for long talks with God. That’s no accident. The writer A. T. Pierson pictured making a decision like using a balance scale. You weigh every factor honestly, and God tips the scale. “But our hands must be off the scales.” In other words, you can’t secretly push for the answer you want. The third guideline follows from this: hearing God doesn’t make you right. It doesn’t even prove you understood him. So “God told me” never ends an argument. As one little sign puts it, “Lord, when we are wrong, make us willing to change, and when we are right, make us easy to live with!” Hearing God is only one part of a whole life with him. So what is that life actually like?

Never Alone

First, it’s a life where you’re never alone. Willard saw how much that means to people when he was in college. He and a small group of students led Thursday night services at a county jail in Tennessee. The inmates were ordinary men serving short sentences, and being cut off from their families hurt them deeply. Almost every week, they asked for the same song. They sang its chorus like desperate men holding on to their last hope: “No, never alone; no, never alone! He promised never to leave me, never to leave me alone.”

Years later, when his first child was born, Willard realized something painful. Nothing he could do would protect his son from cruel people, from his own bad choices, or in the end from death. No person can be with another that completely. Only God can weave himself into the deepest parts of who you are. So anyone who lives in his loving company is never alone. The promise isn’t that nothing bad will happen. It’s that God stays with you, and that’s enough. Your contentment comes from God himself, not from the gifts he gives you.

God is with you in four ways. The first is simple faith. You believe he’s there even when you feel nothing, but your heart can’t live on that alone. The second is feeling that he’s near, and sometimes that feeling is overwhelming. Willard’s oldest brother once prayed late into the night about a decision that would tie him down for years. At 2 a.m., he said, “that room lit up with the glory of God.” He felt a hand on his shoulder and heard a voice say, “Feed my sheep.”

The third is God working alongside you, so you get results far beyond what you could do on your own. The fourth matters most: an ongoing conversation. God talks with you when there’s something to say, the way two people do when they know each other well and are working on something together. Sometimes he speaks in words. But his closest friends often know what he wants just from working beside him, the way a good employee sees what needs doing without being told.

Three common ideas get in the way. The first is “a message a minute”: the belief that God will tell you what to do at every turn. The second is “it’s all in the Bible.” The Bible does hold all the principles you need. But it won’t tell you which song to sing next Sunday. Treating it that way leads to Bible roulette: letting it fall open and pointing at a random verse. You might as well wait for a fly to land on one. The third is the idea that whatever happens must be God’s will. But when Israel worshiped the golden calf and God threatened to destroy them, Moses didn’t just accept it. He pleaded with God, and God changed his mind. Still, some people doubt that God can reach you at all.

Our Communicating Cosmos

Some stories of God speaking are dramatic. Peter Marshall grew up in Scotland and later became chaplain of the United States Senate. As a young man, he was walking home across the moors in northern England on a foggy, pitch-black night. He took a shortcut that ran near a deep, abandoned quarry. As he walked blindly forward, an urgent voice called, “Peter!” He answered, but no one replied. A few steps later, the voice came again, even more urgent: “Peter!” He stopped, stumbled, and fell to his knees. When he reached out to catch himself, there was nothing there. He was on the very edge of the quarry. One more step would have killed him.

Stories like that are fascinating, but they can’t create faith on their own. What people already believe shapes what they’re able to see. And many people have four honest doubts about God speaking to them: he wouldn’t, he doesn’t, he can’t, and he shouldn’t.

Would he? Important people only have time to stay close to a few others. But God’s greatness is exactly what makes him able and willing to speak with you. Jesus welcomed little children, the very people the world treats as unimportant.

Does he? Just because you don’t hear someone doesn’t mean they aren’t speaking. Radio signals pass through you all day, but you hear nothing unless a radio is tuned in. Some honest self-examination may help, too. Are you working with God? Or are you working for yourself, trying to “use a little God” to help your own plans? Before you ask how to hear God, ask what you would do if you heard him.

Can he? Many people assume science has ruled God out. But God doesn’t need to send a signal across space to reach you. As Paul said, “In him we live, and move, and have our being.” Think about how you live in your own body. You aren’t located in any one spot in it, yet every part of it is open to you. God fills the world in a similar way. Once, when an enemy army surrounded the prophet Elisha, his servant panicked. Elisha prayed, “O Lord, please open his eyes.” Suddenly the servant saw the mountain full of horses and chariots of fire. God had been there all along.

Should he? Some pastors worry that people who hear from God will start contradicting their leaders. But think about the difference between a sheepdog and a shepherd. A sheepdog drives the sheep from behind. A shepherd simply calls and walks ahead, trusting the sheep to know the voice of the Great Shepherd. Still, before you act on anything big or unusual, ask God to confirm it three ways: through the Bible, through your circumstances, and through people who know nothing about the situation. So how does God usually speak?

The Still, Small Voice and Its Rivals

Sometimes God speaks in amazing ways. Virginia Lively was an ordinary woman living in the suburbs. One day she started crying for no reason she could understand, and she kept crying for four days. On the fourth morning, she was alone in her living room when she saw a ball of white light rushing toward her. Then it was beside her, and she saw a face. It was Jesus. His eyes held so much love that she knew nothing she had ever done could change it. Years later, while speaking to a church group, she saw those eyes again. They looked at her from a woman in the second row, and then from every person in the room.

Some people would say an experience like that must come from the devil. Others would put her on a pedestal and feel second-class next to her. Experiences like hers do happen, and sometimes they really are from God. But the still, small voice is the best and most valuable way God speaks to you. When God met the prophet Elijah, he wasn’t in the wind, the earthquake, or the fire. He was in a gentle whisper. In a whisper like that, there’s almost nothing outward to see or hear. The message comes as your own thoughts, but it carries the mark of God’s personality.

God also speaks through signs, angels, dreams, a voice you can actually hear, and other people. When Samuel was a boy, he heard a voice call his name in the night. Three times he ran to the old priest Eli, thinking Eli had called him. Finally Eli realized what was happening. He told Samuel to answer, “Speak, Lord, for your servant is listening.” You may need an Eli, too: someone who can help you recognize God’s voice. And God speaks through your own thoughts. The Bible says, “The human spirit is the lamp of the Lord.” It’s as if God walks through your mind with a candle, pointing your attention to one thing after another. So when a thought keeps coming back, stop and prayerfully ask whether it’s from him.

That’s why prayer should be a conversation, not a speech. Rosalind Rinker spent years as a missionary, yet prayer still felt empty to her. One day she was praying with a friend. In the middle of her friend’s prayer, she jumped in to thank God for the very thing her friend was praying about. They both laughed, then kept praying with new joy. Afterward she said, “Instead of each of us making a prayer speech to Him, let’s talk things over with Him.”

When Moses’ sister Miriam and brother Aaron grew jealous of him, God told them that he spoke with Moses “face to face—clearly, not in riddles.” The closer a person walks with God, the clearer and quieter God’s messages tend to be. Jesus never had a vision at all. In fact, the more dramatic the experience, the less mature the person usually is. God’s goal is to walk with you quietly and steadily. And his quiet word turns out to be far more powerful than it sounds.

The Word of God and the Rule of God

A Roman soldier in the Bible shows just how powerful God’s word is. He was a centurion, an officer in charge of about a hundred soldiers, stationed in the town of Capernaum. His servant was lying paralyzed at home. Jesus offered to come and heal him. For Jesus, that was as easy as raising your hand. But the centurion stopped him. He said he wasn’t worthy to have Jesus come into his house. “Just give the order, please, and my servant will recover. I am used to working under orders, and I have soldiers under me.” Jesus was amazed. “I have never found faith like this anywhere.” The centurion simply knew how authority works. Where a ruler’s word goes, power goes with it.

Words carry the thoughts of the person who speaks them, and that gives them huge power. Kids chant, “Sticks and stones may break my bones, but words can never hurt me.” But cruel words on a school playground can scar a child for life. A kingdom doesn’t run on physical force. It runs on words: on thoughts and plans passed from one person to another. God’s kingdom works the same way.

God created the world by speaking. He said, “Let there be light,” and there was light. You can’t do that. You can’t say, “Let there be a chocolate cake,” and get one. You have to work with flour, eggs, and an oven. But there’s one place where your word does work like God’s: your own body. When you decide to move your finger, it just moves. In that small space, your word makes things happen directly, the way God’s does. That helps you picture how he runs the whole world by his word. The laws of nature are his thoughts about how the world should work.

God even shares this power with people. Jesus sent his twelve disciples out to heal the sick. Later he sent out seventy ordinary followers. They came back amazed that even demons obeyed them when they used his name, and Jesus was overjoyed.

If your prayers seem to go nowhere, that can be hard to hear. Once, after Willard gave a talk on prayer, a woman came up to him, crying and angry. She had tried hard to make prayer work. It hadn’t, and she was left feeling guilty and hurt. But making things happen isn’t your job. Your job is only to be honestly willing, even eager, for God to make you able.

That’s also the difference between God’s word and magic. Magic tries to get results without a relationship, as if the power were in the words themselves. In the city of Ephesus, seven traveling exorcists tried using Jesus’ name like a magic spell. The evil spirit answered, “Jesus I know, and Paul I know; but who are you?” Then the man with the spirit jumped on them, and they ran out of the house naked and bleeding. You are under God’s authority, not in control of it.

So where does the Bible fit in? It’s God’s one-of-a-kind written Word. But God’s word is bigger than the Bible. Jesus himself is the living Word. And that living word doesn’t only run the world. It’s also how God changes you.

Redemption Through the Word of God

God’s word doesn’t just give you information. It brings you to life. Being alive means being able to respond to what’s around you. A cabbage is alive, but it can’t play with a ball of string. A kitten can, but math and poetry mean nothing to it. People were made to be alive to God. Adam and Eve talked with their Creator every day. But when they stopped trusting him and disobeyed, they went dead to the spiritual world, just as he had warned. That’s why people need what Jesus called being “born from above.” Picture an ordinary kitten that suddenly starts to love poetry and write it. That’s how big the change is.

Nicodemus, a respected religious teacher, came to Jesus sure that he could recognize God at work. Jesus gently told him he couldn’t. “No one can see the kingdom of God without being born from above.” Without that new birth, you’re like a kitten trying to understand a poem. The apostle Peter wrote that the new birth comes “through the living and enduring word of God.” That word enters your mind like a seed. It takes root in your heart and starts to change your whole personality.

God’s word also washes you, the way soap and water move through a dirty shirt and carry the dirt away. Your mind comes to God full of false beliefs. Maybe you assume that if you’re harsh enough with people, they’ll behave. Or that you get ahead by grabbing what you can. Jesus taught the opposite. So ask yourself an honest question. When your mind is free to wander, does it swing back to God, the way a compass needle swings back to north? One mental health clinic took the coffee out of its waiting room, and the constant arguing there dropped to just two or three bad scenes a week. Toxic thoughts work like that caffeine, pushing you to do things you don’t understand. God’s word washes them out and puts his own thoughts in their place. Where there was fear, now there’s hope. And a mind that’s been washed like that finds it natural to listen for God.

Over time, talking with God grows into a deep closeness, and that closeness grows into oneness. It’s like a married couple who stop saying “mine” and “yours” and just say “ours.” As Paul wrote, “It is no longer I who live, but Christ who lives in me.”

The Bible is central to this change. But read it to live it, not just to learn it. Start with passages you already love, like Psalm 23, and go slowly. The French Christian writer Madame Guyon warned that a fast reader is like “a bee that merely skims the surface of a flower.” Ten verses worked into your life are worth more than the whole Bible rushing past your eyes. Take “The Lord is my shepherd.” At first it may just be a fact: it was true for David. Then comes longing: “I wish the Lord were my shepherd.” Then a prayer: “Lord, make it so for me.” And finally: “It is so.” But how can you tell that the voice you hear is really God’s?

Recognizing the Voice of God

You learn to recognize God’s voice the way you learn any voice: by hearing it again and again. A story about an elephant shows how deep that kind of knowing can go. A circus trainer named Charles Frank raised an elephant named Neeta from birth and taught her to perform. When he retired, he gave her to the San Diego Zoo. Fifteen years later, a TV crew filmed the two of them meeting again. Frank called to her from about a hundred yards away. She came to him at once and did her old tricks on command. After fifteen years apart, she still knew his voice. Jesus said his sheep know his voice the same way. They don’t analyze it. They just know it.

A message that truly comes from God will always agree with the plain meaning of the Bible. Beyond that, the only answer to “How do you know this is from God?” is “By experience.” Many people wait for three “lights” to line up: the Spirit’s nudges inside you, the Bible, and your circumstances. But an open door doesn’t tell you who opened it. So these three lights help most once you already know God’s voice. Still, they’re where his voice usually comes through.

God’s voice has three marks you can learn to recognize. The first is its weight. It has a calm, steady force that makes you want to say yes. The missionary E. Stanley Jones put it this way: “The voice of the subconscious argues with you, tries to convince you; but the inner voice of God does not argue, does not try to convince you. It just speaks, and it is self-authenticating.” In other words, it carries its own proof.

The second mark is its spirit. God’s voice is peaceful, confident, joyful, and kind. When God told Bob Mumford to go back to school, the voice wasn’t pushy or frantic. As Mumford put it, it felt “warm, but firm.” The third mark is its content. What God says always fits the big principles of the Bible, like loving God and loving your neighbor. A young man named Evan Roberts once heard a voice telling him to go home and speak to the young people at his church. He asked his school principal whether the voice might be from the devil. The principal answered, “The devil never gives orders like that.”

Any voice that promises you’ll never suffer or fail is not God’s. And don’t expect Satan to show up looking like a giant bat with bony wings. He comes the same way God does, through your thoughts. But his messages have a different weight, spirit, and content. Even when you’re sure God has spoken, you can still be wrong. But knowing God’s voice protects you from people who claim to speak for him. That includes cult leaders like Jim Jones. It also includes respectable religious people who, like the Pharisees, condemn what God is clearly doing.

Knowing God’s voice also brings peace. One little boy’s mother had died, and nothing could comfort him. So he slept in his father’s room. In the dark he would ask, “Daddy, is your face turned toward me now?” Only when he was sure could he fall asleep. You can get by with a God who never speaks, but it isn’t much of a life. God doesn’t mumble, and he doesn’t play tricks. If he wants you to know something, he’s able and willing to tell you plainly. Even so, there will be times when he says nothing.

A Life More Than Guidance

When God seems silent, start with an honest question: do you really want to hear him? Few people do. You can tell, because they only listen for him when they’re in trouble or facing a decision they can’t handle. People who truly want to hear God want it just as much when life is calm and ordinary. If you’d rather run your own life, your mind will tune out God’s voice or twist it to fit your plans.

So how do you listen? The Christian psychologist James Dobson offered a simple prayer worth writing on your bathroom mirror: “Lord, I need to know what you want me to do, and I am listening. Please speak to me through my friends, books, magazines I pick up and read, and through circumstances.” Willard’s own habit was to ask God to speak, then spend the next hour or so on something ordinary, like housework, gardening, or paying bills. Often by the end of that hour, one idea stood out. It had the weight, spirit, and content he had learned to recognize. If nothing came, he didn’t worry. He left the matter with God and went on with his day. This isn’t a trick for squeezing answers out of God. It matters far more to keep a quiet place inside you that is always listening than to keep asking God for specific directions.

Often, though, God is silent because he wants you to make the choice. He isn’t playing hide-and-seek with you. But think about a child. You can’t know what kind of person she really is, and neither can she, until she’s free to make her own choices. So God may be saying, “In this case, my will is for you to decide.” When God gives no specific word, there may be several good choices, like which job to take or where to live, and each one can be his perfect will for you.

Some silences come from a battle much bigger than you. Even Jesus cried out on the cross, “My God, my God, why have you forsaken me?” Still, there’s something greater than always knowing what to do. Paul said the greatest things are faith, hope, and love. The highest kind of maturity isn’t always hearing God’s voice. It’s standing firm in faith, hope, and love even when he says nothing. God doesn’t exist to solve your problems. You exist to stand with God and make your life count.

So here’s how to live with God’s voice day to day. Do what you already know is right. Talk to God about everything, and listen. When he doesn’t speak, spend a few days asking him whether something in you is blocking him. Get advice from at least two people whose walk with God you respect. Fix whatever needs fixing. Then do what seems best. As Abraham Lincoln said, “I am satisfied that, when the Almighty wants me to do, or not to do, a particular thing, he finds a way of letting me know it.” Your confidence rests in the Lord who goes with you, whose mercies are new every morning.

The Way of the Burning Heart

Even after all this, one obstacle remains. The world you can see is loud and pushy. Few people wake up as hungry for God as they are for their morning toast and eggs. But the spiritual world whispers. God comes so gently that you can easily explain him away, and if you do, he leaves without a fight. He wants to be wanted. If you’re set on explaining him away, he’ll most likely leave you alone. Then you can feel proud that nobody fooled you. That should send a chill down your spine. Our culture says the skeptic is always smarter than the believer. In Willard’s words, “You can be almost as stupid as a cabbage, as long as you doubt.” So you have to bet your life that the world you can see, real as it is, isn’t all there is.

After Jesus rose from the dead, he appeared to his followers only a few times over forty days. His main goal was to get them used to hearing him without seeing him. Two of his heartbroken followers were walking to a village called Emmaus when Jesus joined them on the road. They didn’t recognize him. As they walked, he explained what the Scriptures said about the Messiah. At supper, their eyes were suddenly opened, and they knew who he was. Then he vanished. They said to each other, “Were not our hearts burning within us while he was talking to us on the road?” For three years his words had made their hearts burn like that, and no one else’s words ever had.

Later, on a mountain in Galilee, Jesus sent his followers out to every nation. His last words to them were simple: “Look, I am with you every minute, until the job is done.” He is with you now, and he still speaks. Spiritual people aren’t the ones who practice certain spiritual disciplines. They’re the ones whose life flows from an ongoing conversation with God. Think back to Mema at the Sunday dinner table, wondering why God never spoke to her. She already walked with God. She just needed someone to help her recognize his voice, the way Eli helped young Samuel. You can learn to recognize it, too. Then you can walk your own road to Emmaus, your heart burning as his word comes to you. The world you can see stops being a wall between you and God. It becomes his gift: the place where you walk and talk with him as a friend.

Questions

What Hearing God is about

In Hearing God, Dallas Willard argues that you were made for a conversational relationship with God: a friendship in which God speaks when there is something to say. InterVarsity Press published it in 1999, with a new edition in 2012, as an expanded version of In Search of Guidance, Willard’s first book for Christian readers. God can use dreams, angels or a voice you can hear, but the best way, Willard says, is the still, small voice that comes as thoughts in your own mind. You learn it by experience, by its weight, spirit and content, and by its fit with the Bible. Willard also weighs the “three lights” and explains God’s silences.

Who should read it

The faithful Christian who hears others say “God told me” and quietly wonders why God never speaks that way to them. Someone facing a big decision who wants to understand guidance, or who fears mistaking their own wishes for God’s voice. It suits readers who like careful thinking and many true stories. Readers who believe God now speaks only through the Bible will reject its core claim, and the reviewer Greg Gilbert found its organization “haphazard and often confusing.”

The three marks of God’s voice

  • Weight: a calm, steady force that makes you want to say yes. E. Stanley Jones wrote that the inner voice of God “does not argue, does not try to convince you. It just speaks, and it is self-authenticating.”
  • Spirit: peaceful, confident, joyful and kind, never pushy or frantic. When God told Bob Mumford to go back to school, Mumford said the voice felt “warm, but firm.”
  • Content: what it says always fits the great principles of the Bible, like loving God and loving your neighbor. A voice that promises you will never suffer or fail is not God’s.

Questions people ask

What does Dallas Willard mean by a conversational relationship with God?

A friendship in which God speaks to you when there is something to say, the way two close friends talk while they work on a project together. In Hearing God, Dallas Willard argues that this is the normal life God intended, the life Adam and Eve and Moses knew. Hearing God is only one part of that friendship, and getting directions is only one part of hearing God. So Willard rejects the idea of “a message a minute.” God does not want robots who follow orders, Willard says, but friends whose obedience grows out of love, and God’s closest friends often know what God wants just from working together.

What is the still, small voice in Hearing God?

It is the quiet way God most often speaks: a message that comes as your own thoughts but carries the mark of God’s personality. Dallas Willard takes the picture from the story of Elijah in 1 Kings 19, where God was not in the wind, the earthquake or the fire, but in a gentle whisper. God also speaks through signs, angels, dreams, other people and even a voice you can hear, Willard grants. But Willard calls the still, small voice the best and most valuable way, and says the closer you walk with God, the clearer and quieter God’s messages tend to be. When a thought keeps coming back, stop and ask in prayer whether it is from God.

How does Hearing God say to tell God’s voice from your own thoughts?

By experience, the way you learn any voice: by hearing it again and again. Dallas Willard sets one firm test first. A message that truly comes from God will always agree with the plain meaning of the Bible. Beyond that, you come to know God’s voice by what Willard calls “that peculiar quality, spirit and content that I have come to associate with God’s voice.” Satan also speaks through your thoughts, Willard warns in Hearing God, but with a different weight, spirit and content. Even when you feel sure, you can still be wrong.

What are the three lights in Hearing God?

Circumstances, impressions of the Spirit and passages from the Bible. In Hearing God, Dallas Willard describes how many Christians wait for these three “lights” to line up before they act. Willard grants that they are where God’s voice usually comes through. But the lights cannot replace knowing the voice itself, because an open door doesn’t tell you who opened it. So for Willard, the three lights help most once you already know God’s voice from experience. They are not a formula either: Willard says there is no trick or formula for finding out what God wants.

How do you listen for God’s voice, according to Hearing God?

Ask God to speak, then spend the next hour or so on something ordinary. That was Dallas Willard’s own habit, as Hearing God tells it, with housework, gardening or paying bills. Often one idea stood out by the end of the hour, with the weight, spirit and content Willard had learned to recognize. If nothing came, Willard left the matter with God and went on with the day. It is no trick for squeezing answers out of God, Willard says. What matters more is a quiet place inside you that is always listening. Willard also shares a prayer from James Dobson: “Lord, I need to know what you want me to do, and I am listening.”

What does Hearing God say to do when God is silent?

Keep doing what you already know is right, and keep talking to God and listening. Dallas Willard first asks whether you truly want to hear God when life is calm, not only in a crisis. If God says nothing, spend a few days asking whether something in you is blocking God’s voice, get advice from at least two people whose walk with God you respect, fix what needs fixing, then do what seems best. Often, Willard says in Hearing God, God is silent because God wants you to make the choice. The highest maturity is not always hearing God’s voice, but standing firm in faith, hope and love when God says nothing.

Does Hearing God teach that God speaks outside the Bible?

Yes, but never against it. In Hearing God, Dallas Willard holds that God still speaks to people personally, mostly through the still, small voice, and that every true word agrees with the plain meaning of the Bible, God’s one-of-a-kind written Word. Willard warns against “Bible roulette,” letting it fall open to a random verse, and says “God told me” never ends an argument. Some critics disagree. In a 2002 review for 9Marks, Greg Gilbert wrote, “The Bible is not simply a compendium of various ways that God might speak to us,” and closed, “If you want to know what God says, go to the Scriptures.”

Who was Dallas Willard?

An American philosopher and Christian writer, born in Missouri in 1935, who died in 2013. Dallas Willard spent 48 years teaching philosophy at the University of Southern California and led its School of Philosophy from 1982 to 1985. Willard’s Christian books include The Spirit of the Disciplines (1988), The Divine Conspiracy (1998), Christianity Today’s Book of the Year for 1999, and Renovation of the Heart (2002). Hearing God grew out of In Search of Guidance, Willard’s first book for Christian readers. Willard helped start the ministry Renovaré and shaped writers such as Richard Foster and John Mark Comer.

Free tools built on Hearing God

  • Imaginative Prayer Guide: a free imaginative prayer guide: step into one of 46 Bible scenes as someone who was there, make three choices as AI tells the story, then read the passage with a short teaching, a prayer and a journal entry.

Summaries to read next

Comer’s title comes from Willard’s advice to John Ortberg: “You must ruthlessly eliminate hurry from your life.” Hearing God says the spiritual world whispers while the visible one is loud. Comer builds a slower life around four practices: silence and solitude, Sabbath, simplicity and slowing. Read our summary of The Ruthless Elimination of Hurry by John Mark Comer.

Scazzero turns to the same scene Willard does: God was not in the wind, the earthquake or the fire, but in what the Hebrew calls “a sound of sheer silence.” Emotionally Healthy Spirituality builds that silence into each day with the Daily Office, a few set times to stop and be with God. Read our summary of Emotionally Healthy Spirituality by Pete Scazzero.

Wilkin takes on the question that sends many readers to Hearing God: “What is God’s will for my life?” Her answer starts with the person, not the choice. God cares more about the decision-maker than the decision, so ask “Who should I be?” before “What should I do?” Read our summary of In His Image by Jen Wilkin.

Sources

Facts last checked October 2026.