What Tell Me Where It Hurts is about
Rachel Zoffness’s Tell Me Where It Hurts (Grand Central Publishing, 2026) argues that pain is made by the brain and is biopsychosocial: shaped by biology, by thoughts and emotions, and by the people and places around you. Zoffness, a pain psychologist on the faculty of the UCSF School of Medicine, tells the stories of patients once called untreatable. Part One explains how pain works and why a brain that changes means pain can change. Part Two covers the emotional, cognitive, social and environmental sides of pain, and placebo. Part Three is the Pain Protocol: find your pain recipe, then use biological, emotional, cognitive and social tools.
Who should read it
Anyone with pain that has lasted three months or more, such as back pain, migraines or fibromyalgia, who has tried pills and procedures and still hurts. It also suits the people who love or treat someone in pain, and doctors, nurses and therapists who were never taught pain science. The book does not tell readers to stop medical care: its biological tools come after doctors have ruled out anything dangerous.
The five parts of the Pain Protocol
- Your pain recipe: what turns your pain up, and its opposite
- Biological tools: pacing, sleep, food and movement
- Emotional tools: breathing, mindfulness and pleasant activities
- Cognitive tools: Catch It, Check It, Change It
- Social tools: paced social contact, safe touch and boundaries
Questions people ask
Does Tell Me Where It Hurts say chronic pain is all in your head?
No. In Tell Me Where It Hurts, Rachel Zoffness says pain is never “all in your head,” and it is never purely physical either. Pain is made by the brain, which weighs danger signals from the body together with what you see, remember and feel. Zoffness calls it the body’s alarm, a protective guess about danger. Pain that lasts three months or more is called chronic, and it is often an alarm that sounds when there is no danger. Because the parts of the brain that make pain include the parts that make emotions, Zoffness says treatment has to target biology, psychology and social life together.
What is the Pain Dial in Tell Me Where It Hurts?
It is Rachel Zoffness’s picture for how the nervous system sets pain’s volume, like a knob. In Tell Me Where It Hurts, stress, fear and focusing on pain turn the dial up. Calm, joy and distraction turn it down. One of Zoffness’s examples is Kiran, who had passed kidney stones for years at about 6 out of 10. When Kiran became sure a stone was the stomach cancer that killed her father, her pain shot to 11 out of 10. A scan showed only a kidney stone, and her pain fell to a 3.
What is a pain recipe, according to Rachel Zoffness?
It is the mix of ingredients that sets off your pain flares. In Tell Me Where It Hurts, Rachel Zoffness says everyone has a high-pain recipe, such as poor sleep, stress, junk food or loneliness, and that each one points to its opposite, a low-pain recipe. Joyce, a chef with twenty years of back pain, tracked her pain and saw it rise and fall in one day while her discs never changed. Zoffness tells readers to get a notebook, sort each ingredient under bio, psych or social, and write its opposite beside it.
How does pacing work for chronic pain in Tell Me Where It Hurts?
Pacing means doing a small, set amount of activity every day, on good days and bad days. Rachel Zoffness gives six steps in Tell Me Where It Hurts. Pick a goal that matters to you. Break it into small steps. Time how long you can do the activity on a good day and on a bad day. Average the two. Subtract a couple of minutes as a cushion. Then add a few minutes each week. Sam, a teenager who had been in bed for four years, managed 12 minutes on a good day and zero on a bad one, so Sam started at 4 minutes a day.
Can a placebo work if you know it is a placebo?
Yes, in at least one trial. In Tell Me Where It Hurts, Rachel Zoffness cites a Harvard study in which 60 percent of people with irritable bowel syndrome improved on pills they knew were placebos. The study, led by Ted Kaptchuk and published in PLOS ONE in 2010, reported adequate relief in 59 percent of the open-label placebo group against 35 percent of the group with no treatment, among 80 patients. Zoffness says a placebo works through a ritual, a trusted source, hopeful words and a safe setting, which signal safety to the brain.
Do bulging discs always cause back pain?
No. In Tell Me Where It Hurts, Rachel Zoffness writes that hurt and harm are not the same thing. In scans of people with no back pain, Zoffness says, about 90 percent of those in their sixties had bulging or degenerating discs. A 2015 review in the American Journal of Neuroradiology, covering 3,110 people without symptoms, estimated disc degeneration in 88 percent of 60-year-olds and disc bulges in 69 percent. Zoffness’s other example is the sprinter Usain Bolt, who has scoliosis and says his back does not really bother him.
Is Tell Me Where It Hurts worth reading?
Yes, for readers who want pain explained in plain words and want things to try this week. Rachel Zoffness’s Tell Me Where It Hurts (Grand Central Publishing, 2026) teaches the science through patients’ stories and ends with a protocol for sleep, movement, breathing, thoughts and social life. Readers who want one quick cure will not find one: Zoffness says to expect two steps forward and one step back, and that flares are a normal part of healing. The summary on this page follows the book chapter by chapter in about 25 minutes.
Free tools built on Tell Me Where It Hurts
- Sleep Quality Scorer: a free sleep quality quiz that scores your sleep habits out of 100, ranks what is costing you the most, and gives you a few sleep experiments to try this week.
- Two-Minute Movement Breaks: a free tool that deals one playful two-minute move for where you are and what feels stiff, with three steps, a timer and a twist that turns it into a game.
- 30-Day Gratitude Journal: a free 30-day gratitude journal by text message: a new prompt each day at the time you pick, you reply with three good things, and a short reflection and weekly recaps come back.
Summaries to read next
Zoffness gives ten sleep rules because bad sleep turns pain up. Huberman’s Protocols starts in the same place, with morning daylight, a steady schedule and a cool room, and adds weekly plans for strength and cardio. Read our summary of Protocols by Andrew Huberman.
Zoffness says steady, gradual movement teaches the brain that movement is safe. Ratey’s Spark shows what exercise does inside the brain, where it raises serotonin, norepinephrine and dopamine. Read our summary of Spark by John Ratey.
Zoffness explains how pain works in the brain and body. Keller asks what suffering means, and shows how to walk through it with God: weep, trust, pray, think, thank, love and hope. Read our summary of Walking with God Through Pain and Suffering by Tim Keller.
Sources
Facts last checked November 2026.